Crimes That May Legally Prevent You From Receiving U.S. Citizenship

General Impact of Criminal Records on Citizenship

  • Having a criminal record can pose significant obstacles to U.S. citizenship.
  • USCIS considers crimes committed both in the U.S. and abroad, unless convictions abroad were due to persecution.
  • A criminal record can affect whether the applicant meets the good moral character requirement.
  • USCIS evaluates factors like cooperation with law enforcement, involvement of drugs/alcohol, use of weapons, and harm to victims.
  • Even if no automatic bar applies, USCIS can deny citizenship based on lack of good moral character.

Permanent Bars to Citizenship

  • Permanent bars apply if you have been convicted of:
    • Murder, or
    • An aggravated felony on or after November 29, 1990.
  • USCIS cannot waive or override permanent bars.
  • Such convictions usually lead to removal (deportation) proceedings.
  • Aggravated felony includes certain crimes beyond state felony definitions, including some misdemeanors.
  • Examples of aggravated felonies: rape, child sexual abuse, child pornography, drug and weapons trafficking, fraud above a certain threshold, and illegal smuggling (with some exceptions for family members).
  • Theft or violent crimes with sentences of one year or more are often aggravated felonies.
  • Even lesser crimes like resisting arrest or DUI may count as crimes of violence in some cases.

Removal Risk

  • Convictions of murder or aggravated felony on/after 11/29/1990 lead to automatic removal risk and bar from citizenship.

Temporary Bars to Citizenship

  • Certain crimes result in a temporary bar where the applicant must wait before applying for citizenship.
  • The waiting period typically restarts on the date of the crime committed.
  • Usually, applicants must wait 5 years after the crime, or 3 years in some cases, before applying.
  • USCIS can still deny citizenship if they find a lack of good moral character despite passing the waiting period.

Examples of Crimes with Temporary Bars

  • Prostitution, solicitation, drug possession (except small marijuana possession), and minor fraud.
  • Marijuana possession exception: single offense of 30 grams or less may not trigger a temporary bar, but possession over 30 grams does, regardless of state legality.
  • Serving 180 days or more in jail triggers a temporary bar.
  • Multiple crimes resulting in a combined sentence of 5 years or more trigger a temporary bar.

Disclosure of Arrests and Criminal History

  • On Form N-400 (naturalization application), you must disclose:
    • All convictions,
    • All arrests, and
    • Any crimes you were involved in even if not arrested or if charges were dismissed.
  • Failure to disclose can lead to denial or loss of citizenship later if discovered.
  • Arrests and other records are likely to be found during the USCIS fingerprint check.

Legal Assistance

  • Given the complexity, consulting an immigration attorney is highly recommended.
  • You can use resources like the Justia Lawyer Directory to find experienced immigration lawyers who can assess your record and guide you.

Leave a Reply